Email The Lost Jacket Subcribe to the blog via RSS

Companies Hire People. Not Agencies.

by Stuart Foster on June 29, 2009

company 500x322 Companies Hire People. Not Agencies.

What convinces someone to hire an agency? Is it the awards that they have won? The prestige of the accounts they have handled? Their capabilities? Or does it come down to price?

All of these things factor into the discussion. However, more often than not an agency is hired because of the reputation of people that work there. Companies aren't interested in your capabilities, they are interested in your ability to communicate, produce cohesive ideas, and be a fun person to have around and  be involved in the conversation. Your personal relationship with the company in question will determine the success or failure of the venture.

Client services wouldn't exist if this were not the case. Your agency will get the contract because Bob from Brawndo liked your story on the golf course, not because of your numerous case studies with similar companies demonstrating clear measurables. The case studies are a prerequisite to get you in the door. It's up to your client services people to close that gap from idea to sale.

So how can you best prepare your agency for success? Stock it with badass people. I'm convinced that if you get enough great people in the room, awesome things can happen. However, you also need to have the right mix in order to be successful.

Think of an agency as a community. You have to cultivate, encourage and effectively reward those within that community to be successful. Communities are the best way to enable, empower, and rapidly develop ideas and product offerings.

If this is the case, why manage an agency like a corporation? Wouldn't it make more sense to manage it like a community?

pixel Companies Hire People. Not Agencies.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment, showing us some social love or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this article
  • Bookmark this post on Delicious
  • Stumble this post
  • Upvote this article on Reddit

tagged as , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

You're going to take me to task for a typo? And a then/than mix up at that?

Grow up.

Good points.

Now... what's the use of having cool, fun people if they can't even write correctly? E.g. "More often then not..." instead of "More often than not...". If I get a proposal from a cool, fun guy but he shows me that he can't even write correctly, what kind of quality can I expect from the work I'm supposed to be contracting?

Yea the topic of an agency's community is a good one. From my short, but extremely valuable experience working in an agency last summer, I saw how important it is to have the right team, the right group of people, that can work well together to make the best possible final product. It's absolutely essential. You can do big things when you have a strong team. The power of the agency is that it can combine a lot of great minds into one collaborative force that can accomplish more than any single individual ever could.

Appreciate the love Stuart. Lets team up one day. Ryan too. (=

(1) Excellent post. People are interesting, companies often aren't.

(2) However, the issue I see is that everyone else doesn't have a problem hiring agencies that have won a ton of awards or have numerous case studies. Seriously. Even if the most awesome agency in the world does a crappy job, I really don't any sort of retribution. I mean, "no one ever gets fired for hiring IBM." (figure of speech, I like IBM and I'm sure they are great.) So, how do we change the mindset of clients?

(3) Dropping the Brawndo video = WIN

You should try Sweden. Here they want to know what your education is. Your background and are entirely suspicious of anyone who likes to have fun.
But having said that they are very loyal once you have them as clients.
Nice article may I say.
At the end of the day when everything on the table is equal.... they buy from the person they like!
Take care and get as much joy as you can every day

I think there are a lot of ifs in this equation. Especially for larger agencies in which it is easier to get to know the case studies, awards and general reputation of the agency and more difficult to get to know the actual people that you will be working with. But, from my perspective as the president of a small agency, the idea of community has a lot of appeal. That said, it is essential to create a healthy mix between community and organization. For a small agency, it is extremely important to adopt the different networks that people bring to the table, and not just their individual skill sets. From that standpoint, community is vital. But, you also need to make sure that the community is confined in a space that is benefiting the agency, and not allowing the people to explore too far out. Communities that get loose start new communities. So, if you do treat your agency as a community, you need to make sure that people are driven for the right causes, and are not challenging the core reason they are there. That is where organization comes in.

Ahhh right on. Well I would agree with you there! Can't wait to see you continue exploring it :) Especially now that you're on the agency side!

Exactly. It's about thinking in a way that other people aren't. It takes a mind that's just wired a little wonkily.

I wrote this with certain things in mind (but primarily because I'm interested in the evolving role of the agency). The more I think about this, the more I think it needs to be explored.

I really want to explore the agency as community idea further. This post started out as one thing then evolved into another. The more I think about it the more I like this idea from an organizational standpoint. Fits the current climate far better then the old modus operandus.

I think that "crazy" is the secret sauce that makes an agency better. I'll fully admit that I'm slightly nuts.

Were you writing this to anyone in specific, or just as a point to be made? Just curious!

And you are definitely correct. Take a look at the recent loss of H&R Block as a client by Campbell Mithun. The new CEO/President for H&R, Russ Smyth, had worked at McDonald's for 21 years with DDB, so of course as soon as he steps into H&R he was so comfortable working with DDB that he made an executive decision to stop working with Campbell Mithun, cutting somewhere around $150MM from their revenue stream.

Now, Smyth probably made an appropriate call, as DDB obviously does great work. But was it the right call, a good call? I would say no. He was thinking of just how comfy he was with the people at DDB, and all he say in CM was an agency, since he didn't have/take the time to get to know them.

Then again, I'm not Smyth, so I don't want to be presumptuous. But it just seems like he could have used your article last October ;)

Couldn't agree more Stuart. The services start the conversation, but the people definitely have to finish it. This is why I always like dealing with people that pump out great content and soft-sell. Nobody cares what you THINK you can do. Just be candid and prove it. I get tired of "We feel very confident we can do this for you... ... better than anyone else." "Our services... ... blah blah."

They're just words. They don't mean anything to me. I'd rather you just be honest and say this is what we provide, this account we've had in the past was a similar fit, and here's what we did with that.

I love the notion of the agency as a community, and also the right mix of people. Four all-stars sometimes butt heads. Sometimes a much better mix is two all-stars and 2 brilliant role-players who dominate their respective niches.

And I sincerely hope one day someone types "badass" into Google and I come up based on that hyperlink.

Excellent points. I guy I work with likens it to a zoo. The best agencies are the ones that have the most interesting zoo of people working there.

And I repeatedly suggest that sanity is looked upon too kindly in our industry. The crazier the zoo, the better.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] This post was Twitted by johnheaney [...]