Email The Lost Jacket Subcribe to the blog via RSS

The Downside of Being Provocative

by Stuart Foster on August 3, 2009

Devil

Capturing the attention of others is easy. Making sure that the spotlight doesn't leave is another task entirely. Few companies, brands and people have been successful for long periods of time. Those that do often have an unassailable idea, a ridiculous amount of added value, or they are simply better at what they do than anyone else.

But there is the alternate route: Be consistently provocative, avant garde, and rebellious. It's a tough road, but one worth taking if you think you can parlay it into sustained success. Being professionally provocative is like playing chicken. The key is knowing when to jump out of the car and save yourself from falling off the cliff. However, most people  don't (and can't) make the jump.

Can you hope to remain provocative throughout your entire career? Of course not. Trends shift, ideas come and go, and political and economic realities all come to play a role in your career lifetime. The world at large wants you to fail and fall back to Earth. After all, that would wipe the "smug" expression off your face.

Therein lies the problem for most people that are seen as being "provocative". They don't see themselves as being provocative at all. They merely are trying to establish themselves, create awesome stuff, or let people know how passionate they are about the particular subject they are talking/writing about. After all, have you ever seen a provocative person who wasn't passionate?

Here are some of the likely outcomes for those people who wish to succeed while  being provocative:

1. You run out of material. This is the most likely scenario. People often have a limited amount of creative controversial juices running through them. Eventually they fall back to Earth, become a one trick pony or jump on the wrong trend. Flash doesn't solve everything, guys (just sayin').

2. You could potentially sabotage your career. The more successful, outspoken, and passionate you are about what you are doing? The more enemies you will make. This sadly, is a simple fact of life. People will likely interpret your confidence as arrogance.

3. You could be misunderstood. This happens a lot. Something you say will be taken out of context, you'll be perceived as being arrogant, or you'll just tick off the wrong person. Needless to say, if this happens, you'd better be great at damage control (and being able to fully articulate your position).

4. Your ideas aren't given credence (even when they are right). This one hurts the worst. Countless visionaries have died penniless because no one saw the value in what they were doing until it was to late. I'm not saying this is going to happen...but keep in mind: Mozart died a broke man.

5. You succeed. A rare achievement; accomplished only by those people who can maintain their creative brilliance, outspoken views, and who they are as people. The key to this kind of success? Surrounding yourself with a great team, recognizing and seeking out your weaknesses and tempering some of your more controversial ideas. Don't be the lone gunman.

Being provocative isn't about being controversial. It's about being ahead of your time, solving problems in new and interesting ways, and creating awesome brands and products. Can you succeed at being provocative and being successful? Only time will tell.

pixel The Downside of Being Provocative

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment, showing us some social love or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this article
  • Bookmark this post on Delicious
  • Stumble this post
  • Upvote this article on Reddit

tagged as , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

True. But I can't crush that part of me. Therefore I utilize other outlets to pitch the Iphone ideas and try and keep the big picture thinking at work to a minimum.

I don't completely crush it though, I let it slip out from time to time. Otherwise, I'd probably go crazy.

Stuart, I think a big hurdle - one that I've discussed previously - is the notion of employees focusing too much of their attention on finding the next "big thing". Everyone wants to be innovative and provacative. They want to come off as edgy. So we find a lot of folks racking their brain trying to come up with the next iPhone.

Instead, it's often the little ideas or the "bad ideas" that find the greatest success. So stop looking at the big picture all the time. Quit trying to be the next Facebook. Focus on foundation.

That's where I have seen the most growth in myself over the past 6 months. It's one thing to be contrarian and go against the grain. It's another thing entirely to try and run a business off that concept.

Surrounding yourself with great people (and trying to correct your own flaws) is a must. You need to reassess where you are going constantly and seek the input of others to stay on track.

The trick is this: being able to steer the boat in the direction you want it to go, then stepping back and only directing when it is deemed appropriate. If you can pull that off...you will have a LOT more longevity.

Finding the line between being provocative and effective can be a terrific feat, to be sure. While there will always be naysayers, the trick is to stand firm in your convictions, know what you're talking about, and be able to express your ideas in a way that doesn't make you seem like a total d-bag. going against the grain will always put you in the position of being seen as a boat-rocking pain in the ass, but it's a far better place than never taking control of the oars.

There's a fine line between being provocative [for the heck of it] and being contrarian! So many creative/ brilliant people end up being the lone gunman. A contrarian approach is also routinely misunderstood and degenerates into 'the world doesn't understand me'.

Many creative entrepreneurs fall into the trap of not 'seeing' their weaknesses. The results are painful.

It seems we've thought ourselves into 'its fashionable to be provocative'.

We've not yet learnt how to deal with 'being' contrarian, by doing things differently ie converting thought to action.

This is a well-thought out post Stuart. Well done.

Cheers

Anita Lobo

True. You will end up pissing a certain percentage of the population off (while being adored by the other segment). But here is the inherent problem with that: Like it or not...the percentage that hates you usually is in charge of the status quo. Thus, you are going to have to bend and work within the system whether you like it or not.

Creatives don't run America. The accountants do.

Yeah, sustainability is definitely the name of the game here. I've found through personal experience that you can not pull this off alone. Being provocative is fine...as long as you are smart enough to realize you need to surround yourself with people who can cover your ass, believe in what you are doing and encourage you forward.

Without that outside help...you are almost certainly going to fail.

What is and isn't provocative is definitely dependent on your point of view. Some of us have a higher threshold for change then others. Those that are on the cutting edge usually tick off the general populace anyway. Why would provocateurs be any different?

You can't fake it though. You'll get crucified if you even try.

That one person seems to cause a lot of trouble don't they?

Not taking an objective view and examining a person's views on face value is not enough. You need to take a deeper dive and really see if you can find out more before jumping to a conclusion.

Thanks for this post. A lot of truth here.

The point I focused most on was point #3: It is easy to be misunderstood. You're right, it is VERY easy to be misunderstood, and the more provocative and "out there" you are, the more likely this is to happen.

However, being provocative also means that people who read your work have a much harder time being ambivalent to it. Either they will shy away from it because it is 'too strong,' or they will embrace it... (OK, so these are the two extremes, but the more out there you are, the more they will be forced to make a decision). This is good because, even though you might end up with a smaller fan base and you might piss some people off, the remainder of your readership will likely be quite committed to you and your work.

Just some of my thoughts on the matter... Enjoying the other comments :)

Stuart

I think you last point is the best... while it's pretty easy to be disagreeable for eternity, maintaining creative brilliance is far more difficult, especially when you consider how fast things change in our world these days.

To stay ahead of the curve and maintain a knowledge base which gives you the context necessary for positive provocation simply requires a ton of work and commitment. It is here where I think most will fall down.
@TomMartin

This is a great post. It seems like when companies or individuals try to be provocative for the sake of followers/sales/dollars/whatever it can work on a limited basis but in the long run this tact fails because the audience can quickly see this for what it is. When a company's or individual's authentic voice and/or message is perceived as provocative on a consistent basis there is much better chance of long-term success. Much also has to do with the definition of "provocative." What is provocative to one is mundane to another. Of course, this also shifts over time. Getting a good read on the desired audience, as always, is key.

True. But I can't crush that part of me. Therefore I utilize other outlets to pitch the Iphone ideas and try and keep the big picture thinking at work to a minimum.

I don't completely crush it though, I let it slip out from time to time. Otherwise, I'd probably go crazy.

Stuart, I think a big hurdle - one that I've discussed previously - is the notion of employees focusing too much of their attention on finding the next "big thing". Everyone wants to be innovative and provacative. They want to come off as edgy. So we find a lot of folks racking their brain trying to come up with the next iPhone.

Instead, it's often the little ideas or the "bad ideas" that find the greatest success. So stop looking at the big picture all the time. Quit trying to be the next Facebook. Focus on foundation.

That's where I have seen the most growth in myself over the past 6 months. It's one thing to be contrarian and go against the grain. It's another thing entirely to try and run a business off that concept.

Surrounding yourself with great people (and trying to correct your own flaws) is a must. You need to reassess where you are going constantly and seek the input of others to stay on track.

The trick is this: being able to steer the boat in the direction you want it to go, then stepping back and only directing when it is deemed appropriate. If you can pull that off...you will have a LOT more longevity.

True. But I can't crush that part of me. Therefore I utilize other outlets to pitch the Iphone ideas and try and keep the big picture thinking at work to a minimum.

I don't completely crush it though, I let it slip out from time to time. Otherwise, I'd probably go crazy.

Stuart, I think a big hurdle - one that I've discussed previously - is the notion of employees focusing too much of their attention on finding the next "big thing". Everyone wants to be innovative and provacative. They want to come off as edgy. So we find a lot of folks racking their brain trying to come up with the next iPhone.

Instead, it's often the little ideas or the "bad ideas" that find the greatest success. So stop looking at the big picture all the time. Quit trying to be the next Facebook. Focus on foundation.

That's where I have seen the most growth in myself over the past 6 months. It's one thing to be contrarian and go against the grain. It's another thing entirely to try and run a business off that concept.

Surrounding yourself with great people (and trying to correct your own flaws) is a must. You need to reassess where you are going constantly and seek the input of others to stay on track.

The trick is this: being able to steer the boat in the direction you want it to go, then stepping back and only directing when it is deemed appropriate. If you can pull that off...you will have a LOT more longevity.

Finding the line between being provocative and effective can be a terrific feat, to be sure. While there will always be naysayers, the trick is to stand firm in your convictions, know what you're talking about, and be able to express your ideas in a way that doesn't make you seem like a total d-bag. going against the grain will always put you in the position of being seen as a boat-rocking pain in the ass, but it's a far better place than never taking control of the oars.

There's a fine line between being provocative [for the heck of it] and being contrarian! So many creative/ brilliant people end up being the lone gunman. A contrarian approach is also routinely misunderstood and degenerates into 'the world doesn't understand me'.

Many creative entrepreneurs fall into the trap of not 'seeing' their weaknesses. The results are painful.

It seems we've thought ourselves into 'its fashionable to be provocative'.

We've not yet learnt how to deal with 'being' contrarian, by doing things differently ie converting thought to action.

This is a well-thought out post Stuart. Well done.

Cheers

Anita Lobo

True. You will end up pissing a certain percentage of the population off (while being adored by the other segment). But here is the inherent problem with that: Like it or not...the percentage that hates you usually is in charge of the status quo. Thus, you are going to have to bend and work within the system whether you like it or not.

Creatives don't run America. The accountants do.

Yeah, sustainability is definitely the name of the game here. I've found through personal experience that you can not pull this off alone. Being provocative is fine...as long as you are smart enough to realize you need to surround yourself with people who can cover your ass, believe in what you are doing and encourage you forward.

Without that outside help...you are almost certainly going to fail.

What is and isn't provocative is definitely dependent on your point of view. Some of us have a higher threshold for change then others. Those that are on the cutting edge usually tick off the general populace anyway. Why would provocateurs be any different?

You can't fake it though. You'll get crucified if you even try.

That one person seems to cause a lot of trouble don't they?

Not taking an objective view and examining a person's views on face value is not enough. You need to take a deeper dive and really see if you can find out more before jumping to a conclusion.

Thanks for this post. A lot of truth here.

The point I focused most on was point #3: It is easy to be misunderstood. You're right, it is VERY easy to be misunderstood, and the more provocative and "out there" you are, the more likely this is to happen.

However, being provocative also means that people who read your work have a much harder time being ambivalent to it. Either they will shy away from it because it is 'too strong,' or they will embrace it... (OK, so these are the two extremes, but the more out there you are, the more they will be forced to make a decision). This is good because, even though you might end up with a smaller fan base and you might piss some people off, the remainder of your readership will likely be quite committed to you and your work.

Just some of my thoughts on the matter... Enjoying the other comments :)

Stuart

I think you last point is the best... while it's pretty easy to be disagreeable for eternity, maintaining creative brilliance is far more difficult, especially when you consider how fast things change in our world these days.

To stay ahead of the curve and maintain a knowledge base which gives you the context necessary for positive provocation simply requires a ton of work and commitment. It is here where I think most will fall down.
@TomMartin

This is a great post. It seems like when companies or individuals try to be provocative for the sake of followers/sales/dollars/whatever it can work on a limited basis but in the long run this tact fails because the audience can quickly see this for what it is. When a company's or individual's authentic voice and/or message is perceived as provocative on a consistent basis there is much better chance of long-term success. Much also has to do with the definition of "provocative." What is provocative to one is mundane to another. Of course, this also shifts over time. Getting a good read on the desired audience, as always, is key.

True. But I can't crush that part of me. Therefore I utilize other outlets to pitch the Iphone ideas and try and keep the big picture thinking at work to a minimum.

I don't completely crush it though, I let it slip out from time to time. Otherwise, I'd probably go crazy.

Stuart, I think a big hurdle - one that I've discussed previously - is the notion of employees focusing too much of their attention on finding the next "big thing". Everyone wants to be innovative and provacative. They want to come off as edgy. So we find a lot of folks racking their brain trying to come up with the next iPhone.

Instead, it's often the little ideas or the "bad ideas" that find the greatest success. So stop looking at the big picture all the time. Quit trying to be the next Facebook. Focus on foundation.

That's where I have seen the most growth in myself over the past 6 months. It's one thing to be contrarian and go against the grain. It's another thing entirely to try and run a business off that concept.

Surrounding yourself with great people (and trying to correct your own flaws) is a must. You need to reassess where you are going constantly and seek the input of others to stay on track.

The trick is this: being able to steer the boat in the direction you want it to go, then stepping back and only directing when it is deemed appropriate. If you can pull that off...you will have a LOT more longevity.

Finding the line between being provocative and effective can be a terrific feat, to be sure. While there will always be naysayers, the trick is to stand firm in your convictions, know what you're talking about, and be able to express your ideas in a way that doesn't make you seem like a total d-bag. going against the grain will always put you in the position of being seen as a boat-rocking pain in the ass, but it's a far better place than never taking control of the oars.

There's a fine line between being provocative [for the heck of it] and being contrarian! So many creative/ brilliant people end up being the lone gunman. A contrarian approach is also routinely misunderstood and degenerates into 'the world doesn't understand me'.

Many creative entrepreneurs fall into the trap of not 'seeing' their weaknesses. The results are painful.

It seems we've thought ourselves into 'its fashionable to be provocative'.

We've not yet learnt how to deal with 'being' contrarian, by doing things differently ie converting thought to action.

This is a well-thought out post Stuart. Well done.

Cheers

Anita Lobo

True. You will end up pissing a certain percentage of the population off (while being adored by the other segment). But here is the inherent problem with that: Like it or not...the percentage that hates you usually is in charge of the status quo. Thus, you are going to have to bend and work within the system whether you like it or not.

Creatives don't run America. The accountants do.

Yeah, sustainability is definitely the name of the game here. I've found through personal experience that you can not pull this off alone. Being provocative is fine...as long as you are smart enough to realize you need to surround yourself with people who can cover your ass, believe in what you are doing and encourage you forward.

Without that outside help...you are almost certainly going to fail.

What is and isn't provocative is definitely dependent on your point of view. Some of us have a higher threshold for change then others. Those that are on the cutting edge usually tick off the general populace anyway. Why would provocateurs be any different?

You can't fake it though. You'll get crucified if you even try.

That one person seems to cause a lot of trouble don't they?

Not taking an objective view and examining a person's views on face value is not enough. You need to take a deeper dive and really see if you can find out more before jumping to a conclusion.

Thanks for this post. A lot of truth here.

The point I focused most on was point #3: It is easy to be misunderstood. You're right, it is VERY easy to be misunderstood, and the more provocative and "out there" you are, the more likely this is to happen.

However, being provocative also means that people who read your work have a much harder time being ambivalent to it. Either they will shy away from it because it is 'too strong,' or they will embrace it... (OK, so these are the two extremes, but the more out there you are, the more they will be forced to make a decision). This is good because, even though you might end up with a smaller fan base and you might piss some people off, the remainder of your readership will likely be quite committed to you and your work.

Just some of my thoughts on the matter... Enjoying the other comments :)

Stuart

I think you last point is the best... while it's pretty easy to be disagreeable for eternity, maintaining creative brilliance is far more difficult, especially when you consider how fast things change in our world these days.

To stay ahead of the curve and maintain a knowledge base which gives you the context necessary for positive provocation simply requires a ton of work and commitment. It is here where I think most will fall down.
@TomMartin

This is a great post. It seems like when companies or individuals try to be provocative for the sake of followers/sales/dollars/whatever it can work on a limited basis but in the long run this tact fails because the audience can quickly see this for what it is. When a company's or individual's authentic voice and/or message is perceived as provocative on a consistent basis there is much better chance of long-term success. Much also has to do with the definition of "provocative." What is provocative to one is mundane to another. Of course, this also shifts over time. Getting a good read on the desired audience, as always, is key.

A well thought out post, thanks.

In my experience, it can only take one person misunderstanding your standpoint to set off a wave of indignation from those that will jump on what they see as a popular bandwagon without actually investigating the source themselves.

Tabloid newspapers seem to have turned this "handing out opinions to those unable to form their own" phenomenon into something of an artform.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] friend Stuart Foster wrote about the downside of being provocative today. If you haven’t read it, you should. Because as more companies decide to engage in social [...]

  2. [...] blog I read suggested, “Being provocative isn’t about being controversial. It’s about being ahead of your time, [...]

  3. Being Provocative On The Internetz | The Internet Marketing Spot says:

    [...] friend Stuart Foster wrote about the downside of being provocative today. If you haven’t read it, you should. Because as more companies decide to engage in social [...]