Andrew Swenson is marketing strategist in St. Louis. He is a believer of youth in biz, lover of indie rock, and blogger at wordpost.org.
Consider the fact that while 59% marketers will spend more on social media this year, some 75% of them haven't been able to demonstrate concrete returns.
If 2010 is the year of social media measurement, the year when we finally gain the experience we need to prove ROI, then we must focus our decision-making on what social relationships are doing for our bottom line, not some empty rhetoric about ROI as "return on influence."
In short, we must focus on our customer relationships not just from a relational standpoint, but from a transactional standpoint. We must segment, analyze and follow the money.
Segment
A few days ago, Olivier Blanchard passed along a version of this tweet with the hashtag #notsosure:
Social media projected to be 48% of brand experience in 2010 - Anne Greer, 3M. #tcbimage
And we shouldn't be so sure. Whether Anne Greer actually uttered the statement is beside the point. It's this kind of audacious claim that strikes needless panic in the offices of executives.
But brand experience in "social media" is far too broad to be useful. The only way to know which social tools and networks to target, is to segment your customers not just by purchase history or demographic information, but by the social ecosystem in which the participate. It could be that your customers hate Facebook (or at least won't fan you there).
Remember, there is a REASON [different segments of your customer base] spend their time within the social ecosystem on Yelp and not Facebook – because that’s the community they PREFER.
And sure, we've established that social relationships are a far better way to market than traditional advertising, but maybe traditional tools work just fine for your business.
I once worked with a client who spent roughly 17% of their marketing budget creating and sending an annual catalog. In surveys, nearly 80% of their customers had no interaction with the brand online. They purchased solely because they received a dopey catalog.
Analyze
In considering where to spend social media dollars, it's important not only to have a sense of which ecosystems to target, it's also important to analyze what's hurting your bottom line.
For my catalog client, their cost of new customer acquisition was far too high ( 83% of their marketing budget was spent on 20% of their customer base).
For others, slow and unresponsive customer service may be causing customer attrition.
For others, new product innovation may be stale (and in need of a good dose of crowdsourcing).
And for some, a lack of solid website content may be the root cause of less than stellar traffic.
Finding areas of weakness allows you to target and measure specific action in your social media strategy. Trying to convince the 80% of my catalog client's customers to follow them on Facebook would be a waste of time and money. They aren't interested in that ecosystem.
(As a caveat, if you need help measuring how your social strategies are working to improve your weaknesses, check out Amber Naslund's excellent series on practical social media measurement).
Follow the money
We can talk about how much social media builds better customer relationships, or fosters innovation, or helps spread happiness and rainbows all we want.
But in the end, social media actions should be tied in some way to the bottom line (not always the top line).
In order to figure out where are efforts are best served, however, we must define how and where our customers interact, and match the potential of relationships in those ecosystems to organizational weaknesses that are currently unsupported.
Sorry social media gurus, it's not all about relationships. It's about the money too.
Photo Credit: carolyncoles
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment, showing us some social love or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.
tagged as social analysis, social marketing, social measurement, social media segmenting, social metrics, social roi, social segmenting

Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by BlogManana: New @StuartFoster Smart Social Marketing: Segment, Analyze, and Follow the Money http://bit.ly/cvWt4o...
[...] Public Relations Matters » Blog Archive » AP Style Bootcamp 2 Likes Smart Social Marketing: Segment, Analyze, and Follow the Money Consider the fact that while 59% marketers will spend more on social media this year, some 75% [...]
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Adam Cohen, Ben Kunz, Korye Logan, cloudspark, Peter Imbres and others. Peter Imbres said: Agree with @StuartFosteR in following the money and spending less time quantifying relationships http://bit.ly/bOoQzS [...]
[...] Can you quickly and easily demonstrate social media’s value to the bottom line? [...]
[...] an enlightening left-brain take on Social Media Marketing. Andrew Swenson explains why it’s not just about building [...]