Email The Lost Jacket Subcribe to the blog via RSS

Out With a Whimper, Not a Bang

by Stuart Foster on February 20, 2009

@Amyvernon and @Stuartcfoster

digg Out With a Whimper, Not a Bang

Way back in August – that’s like 8 years for those using the site — Digg went on a banning spree, kicking off users left and right for using scripts that, for the most part, enhanced the Digg experience rather than cheating it.

Many of the users left and never came back. Many came back over and over. And over. They were banned each time it was discovered they were a previously banned user. It came in waves, in September. In October. In December.
Some were accused of using scripts. Some of being previously banned. One, the site's No. 3 Digger of all time, Zaibatsu, was banned for reasons that still seem vague. Reg can explain things for himself: Reg's Explanation

Each time the ban hammer fell, those left on the site would dust off their friends lists, removing those who were gone and making room for new (or old) friends. There were temporary revolts after each banning - members threatened to move to Mixx, to Reddit , to other sites. But in the end, they came back because, after all, this was Digg. The BMOC.

While Digg was declining (or not declining in the mind of various VC investors) a new power was rising. Twitter has grown from a small site with minimal usage until the 2007 SXSW to a huge phenomenon. Twitterati have sprung up that rival the traffic driving power of even the infamous MrBabyMan.

Personality, spunk and a general humorous outlook are all signs of a great digger. As is an innate ability to locate and find popular content for others to enjoy. These qualities allowed Digg to grow into the site it is today. Twitter operates on much of the same principle; only on a more rapid and fluid level. Over time Diggers started becoming active on Twitter. Sure, at first, half the reason was to use it as another means of getting diggs. But soon it became an end rather than a means.

As it became harder to break out to the front page on Digg, Twitter reached a tipping point, where a tweet about something truly interesting could become viral and draw more traffic than any non-FP on Digg could. With the amount of stories coming into Digg each day, content gets lost. Great stories and articles might be seen by two people. When a content site begins to lose out on valuable content: something is wrong.

When you offer disillusioned souls a chance for redemption: they take it. None demonstrates this more prominently than Zaibatsu. Having been tossed off of Digg, Reg used his natural content finding ability to amass a HUGE amount of followers in a relatively short amount of time. What was his secret? The same one he had on Digg: content, content, content.

Digg is only as good as its users and the content that they provide to the site. It's a great feeling finding awesome content and if you are lucky enough meeting the author/creator of that awesome content. Twitter allows for that transition to be seamless. You can connect immediately with the blog owner or artist with a simple @. No framework is holding you back. Transparency, communication, and a sense of community all exist on Twitter...and the invitation is open to everyone.

This new kind of transparency is the kind of thing top users of Digg have been advocating since the site began. Communication is key in order to build a thriving community. Twitter is now the best place to do that. Being able to connect, talk with people and explore is really what the internet is all about. Take away those simple things and you will create malcontent very quickly.

Will Digg survive this exodus of talented content providers loyal to their site? Maybe. But the glory days of Digg being the first thing you look at for something cool/groundbreaking are long gone.

twitter vs digg 500x388 Out With a Whimper, Not a Bang

Related Posts with Thumbnails

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment, showing us some social love or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this article
  • Bookmark this post on Delicious
  • Stumble this post
  • Upvote this article on Reddit

tagged as , , , ,

You're a moderator for http://thelostjacket.com Site admin
You're following this conversation Unfollow
Conversation 
Sign in and Post
Peter moderator
Pending approval

I left Digg for Mixx more than a year-and-a-half ago. It was the best social media-related decision I ever made. Mixx long ago surpassed Digg in site quality, user experience, as well as the strength of character of the community itself and the users it is comprised of. Digg's days are numbered....

Approve comment
Peter moderator
Pending approval

I left Digg for Mixx more than a year-and-a-half ago. It was the best social media-related decision I ever made. Mixx long ago surpassed Digg in site quality, user experience, as well as the strength of character of the community itself and the users it is comprised of. Digg's days are numbered....

Approve comment
Peter moderator
Pending approval

I left Digg for Mixx more than a year-and-a-half ago. It was the best social media-related decision I ever made. Mixx long ago surpassed Digg in site quality, user experience, as well as the strength of character of the community itself and the users it is comprised of. Digg's days are numbered....

Approve comment
Peter moderator
Pending approval

I left Digg for Mixx more than a year-and-a-half ago. It was the best social media-related decision I ever made. Mixx long ago surpassed Digg in site quality, user experience, as well as the strength of character of the community itself and the users it is comprised of. Digg's days are numbered....

Approve comment
cyndezu moderator
Pending approval

Digg has become the school yard bully whose rules are, because I said so. It's run by a bunch of irrational, belligerent punks that are building the next Disneyland for news. Great place for the kids to go, Enjoy!

Approve comment
Elidet moderator
Pending approval

Hey, Kevin Rose, Remember the time the feminist came on and started talking smack about digg and she got booted off front page and said digg was sexist, so THEN I wrote an article and defended digg and had 1900+ diggs, then Jen from booted it off front page because I was defending guys on digg and I was being sexists against GIRLS? Did I tell you I was the girl defending digg? And you bowed down to the crap talker? Yeah. Good times, If by banning people who contribute great things to your site is a way of saying thank you, you should probably not be running digg. @elidet

Approve comment
Jeff Flowers moderator
Pending approval

I wasn't too upset about the bannings back in September. To be honest, it became a better community, because the majority of the spammers were gone. The amount of shouts I receieved dropped instantly. The content was better. It was nice. But, I need to do like Reg and build up my twitter account. Because I don't believe that digg is ever going to pull out of their funk. It's a sinking ship.

Approve comment
Michael moderator
Pending approval

Great post. I had shared some complimentary thoughts on this topic as well recently. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-garrity/w...

Approve comment
Colin Principe moderator
Pending approval

Regrettably the signal to noise ratio on Digg has increased significantly in the past 12 months. Most of the front-page stories in each category are top-10 lists from one site or another. The vibe is much more sophmoric.

Approve comment
Mike Atkins moderator
Pending approval

Digg has become a joke most of the stories on the front page can be found by surfing about 8 very popular sites, you just never discover anything new or interesting there anymore. They banned so many users and so many websites that now it simply feels that your looking at an RSS feed of a tired and small group of Digg friendly sites. http://www.ebizmba.com/articles/social-bookmarking

Approve comment
Stuartfoster moderator
Pending approval

Great quote from Victor Barrera...couldn't find a place for it in the piece...but it's awesome. I actually asked the Twitter community for content and got these responses about the current situation: "Twitter is revolutionizing the way we think of social news. Digg was great, and was fun to be a part of, but it's steadily becoming something completely different than what we used to experience. Twitter offers something fresh, new, and dynamic that is steadily offering more relevant knowledge to the average web-based infomaniac." ~Victor Barrera, Twitter user.

Approve comment

Trackbacks

  1. buzzup.com says:

    Out With a Whimper, Not a Bang…

    Way back in August – that’s like 8 years for those using the site — Digg went on a banning spree, kicking off users left and right for using scripts that, for the most part, enhanced the Digg experience rather than cheating it….